• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Leta Blake

author. human. working hard to become stellar at life.

  • Home
  • Books
    • Contemporary
      • North’s Pole
      • Punching the V-Card
      • Cowboy Seeks Husband
      • Mr. Christmas
        • Mr. Frosty Pants
        • Mr. Naughty List
        • Mr. Jingle Bells
      • My December Daddy
      • Any Given Lifetime
      • Training Season
        • Training Season
        • Training Complex
      • Wake Up Married
      • Will & Patrick Wake Up Married, Episodes 1 – 3
      • Will & Patrick Wake Up Married, Eps 4 – 6
      • Will & Patrick’s Endless Honeymoon
      • Smoky Mountain Dreams
      • The River Leith
      • Vespertine
      • The Difference Between
      • Stay Lucky
      • Bring On Forever
    • Omegaverse
      • Heat of Love
        • White Heat
        • Slow Heat
        • Alpha Heat
        • Slow Birth
        • Winter’s Truth
        • Bitter Heat
        • Winter’s Heart
      • Heat for Sale
        • Heat for Sale
        • Bully for Sale
    • Fantasy
      • Raise Up, Heart
      • Gay Fairy Tales
        • Levity
        • Flight
      • Omega Mine: Search for a Soulmate
      • Any Given Lifetime
      • Angel Undone
    • New Adult
      • ’90s Universe
        • My Skin Begs You Please
        • 90’s Coming of Age
          • Pictures of You
          • You Are Not Me
          • Only You
    • Audiobooks
  • Translations
    • French
      • Bulletin
      • Titres autonomes
        • À l’ombre de Smoky Mountain Dreams
        • Dans n’importe quelle vie
        • La chute de l’ange
        • Le coeur ne ment pas
        • Le Retour de Leith
        • Monsieur Frosty
        • Monsieur Naughty
        • Vespéral
      • Entrainement
        • Saison d’entrainement
        • Centre d’entrainement
        • Entraînement: Intégrale
      • Passion
        • La montée de la passion: Passion #1
        • La passion de l’Alpha: Passion #2
        • Une passion amère: Passion #3
      • Se réveiller mariés
        • Will & Patrick (se réveiller mariés : épisode 1)
        • Will & Patrick rencontrent la famille ( se réveiller mariés : épisode 2)
        • Will & Patrick traversent les fêtes ( se réveiller mariés : épisode 3)
        • Will & Patrick combattent leurs sentiments ( se réveiller mariés : épisode 4)
        • Will & Patrick rencontrent la mafia: se réveiller mariés #5
        • La fin heureuse de Will & Patrick: se réveiller mariés #6
        • La lune de miel de Will & Patrick: Se réveiller mariés #7
        • Se réveiller mariés: Intégrale
      • Tentations
        • Lévitation: un conte de fées gay
        • Envol : un conte de fées gay
      • Vers la vie adulte
        • Vers la vie adulte #1
        • Vers la vie adulte #2
    • Italian
      • Notiziario
      • Titoli indipendenti
        • North’s Pole: Un pacco per Natale
        • Cowboy cerca marito
        • Vespertine : Edizione italiana
        • Smoky Mountain Dreams: Edizione italiana
        • In ogni singola vita
        • Un uomo fortunato
        • Un fiume in piena
        • Le Differenze
        • ANGELO IMPERFETTO
        • La leggerezza del principe
        • Rise: Una favola gay
      • ’90s Coming of Age – Versione italiana
        • Ritratti Di Te (’90s Coming of Age Vol. 1)
        • Tu non sei me (’90s Coming of Age Vol. 2)
      • Calore d’Amore
        • Slow Heat: Calore Inatteso
        • Calore Proibito
        • Calore Amaro
      • Calore in vendita
        • Calore in vendita
      • Home for the Holidays – Versione italiana
        • Cuore di ghiaccio (Home for the Holidays Vol. 1)
        • La lista dei cattivi (Home for the Holidays Vol.2)
      • La stagione dell’allenamento
        • Training Season: La stagione dell’allenamento
        • Training Complex: Il complesso dell’allenatore
      • Svegliarsi sposati
        • Svegliarsi sposati (Wake Up Married Vol. 1)
        • Svegliarsi sposati 2 & 3: Will e Patrick incontrano la famiglia (Wake Up Married 2 & 3)
        • Svegliarsi sposati 4 & 5: Will e Patrick combattono i loro sentimenti – Will e Patrick incontrano la mafia (Wake Up Married 4& 5)
        • Svegliarsi sposati: Il lieto fine di Will e Patrick – La luna di miele infinita di Will e Patrick (Vol 6 & 7) (Wake up married)
    • German
      • Die einbändige
        • Auch in diesem Leben
        • Das Herz findet immer einen Weg
        • Heat for Sale – Deutsche
        • Mr Frosty Pants (German)
        • Mr. Naughty List (German)
        • Smoky Mountain Dreams – Deutsche Version
        • Stay Lucky– Deutsche
        • Vespertine: Der Priester und der Rockstar
      • In der Hitze der Liebe
        • Langsame Hitze
        • Alpha-Hitze
        • Langsame Geburt
        • Bittere Hitze
      • Training Season – Deutsche Version
        • Training Season – Deutsche
        • Training Complex – Deutsche
      • Überraschend … verheiratet!
        • Überraschend … verheiratet! (Wake up Married 1)
        • Überraschend … verliebt! (Wake up Married 2)
        • Will & Patrick: Endlose Flitterwochen: Wake up Married Bonusstory
      • Newsletter
    • Spanish
      • Sueños en las Montañas Humeantes
  • About

stars

Goodreads Rating System – Stars In Confusion

April 8, 2013 by Leta

So, I made a post last week about some things I don’t get, some more controversial than others. Today I’m going to post about something I think every author and reader can agree on “not getting”.   The Goodreads rating system.

For example, in what world does two stars equal “it was okay”? Do you look at a two star rating on a book and think the person liked the book? Heck no. You think, “Wow, they didn’t like this book, but it wasn’t the worst thing they’ve ever read in their life either.” But apparently in Goodreads world, two stars means “it was okay”. I don’t understand.

five-star-rating
This rating system makes sense to me.

In my mental star system (where Jean-Luc Picard reigns in naked glory like the time when the Borg kidnapped him), it works more like this:

One star = Loathed this book and think it sucks like a massive black star of suck.

Two stars = This book was pretty bad, but I’ve read worse.

Three stars = The book was incredibly mediocre but the author could spell and use commas, even though it was dull and I almost didn’t finish it.

Four stars = Yay, I liked it!

Five stars = Yay, I liked it a hell of a lot!

So, here’s my question–when you rate at Goodreads do you use their star system or your own mental star system? And does your star system more closely resemble mine or Goodreads’?

Also, what about rounding up? If you feel like the book was really 1.5 stars, do you give it the benefit of the doubt and round it up? Or do you stick it with the lower number because you’d hate to mislead people?

Another thing I’ve noticed about Goodreads–some people give stars based only only literary merit and not how much they enjoyed the book. I got a few emails from a friend proclaiming that she was crazy about a book featuring gay football players in love, couldn’t stop thinking about it, spent the whole day at work wishing she was home and could read the book. When it was over I got a text reporting that she was sad the book was done and the ending had been just what she wanted. Yet, on Goodreads, she gave the book only three stars. When I asked her why, she said, that it was a great read and she’d loved it a lot, but it was no Deathless or Fortress of Solitude.

This was fascinating to me because I always like to give stars based on the books effectiveness in its genre. If it’s erotica, did it engage me and get me titillated? If it’s romance, did I fall in love too? If it’s literature, was I impressed by the words and the craftsmanship? If it’s fantasy, how was the world building? If it’s self-help, was it actually, you know, helpful? If it’s a children’s book, will actual small children enjoy it? If it’s a spy novel, was it exciting and did I guess the end before it was over? If it was historical fiction, was it well researched?

I couldn't resist.
I couldn’t resist.

It had seemed to me, from the outside in, that the gay football players in love novel had been a total five stars for her in terms of it being a book that did what it was written to do. But she rated on how it worked as literature, not how she reacted to the book in the context of what it was designed for. And that’s her prerogative and one of the things that makes Goodreads a confusing mire when it comes to interpreting the ratings given to a book.

What are your thoughts on the Goodreads rating system? How do you use it?

 

ETA: I wrote this post a month ago or more, and I honestly have no idea what Jean Luc Picard has to do with any of it. Just…you know…go with it.

Filed Under: books, Reviews Tagged With: goodreads, rating, stars, things i don't get

Footer

Search

Follow Me

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • tiktok
  • amazon
  • book

Join Us

Copyright © 2023 · Leta Blake - All Rights Are Reserved · Designed by SloanJ Designs